MetaBOT at 13:56, 8 July 2023

2023-07-08T13:56:12Z

New page

{{Infobox election
| election_name = Jammu and Kashmir Praja Sabha election, 1934
| country = British India
| type = legislative
| ongoing = no
| election_date = {{Start date|df=y|1934|09|03}}{{sfnp|Dalal, The Jammu and Kashmir State Assembly|1935|p=143}}
| next_election = Jammu and Kashmir Legislative Assembly election, 1938
| next_year = 1938
| seats_for_election= 33 seats of 75 seats in Praja Sabha
| majority_seats =
| opinion_polls =
| turnout =

| party1 = [[Jammu & Kashmir National Conference |Muslim Conference]]
| leader1 = [[Sheikh Abdullah]]
| leader_since1 =
| leaders_seat1 =
| last_election1 =
| seats1 = 16
| seat_change1 =

| party2 = Liberal Group
| leader2 = Ram Chander Dubey<ref name=Dubey/>
| leader_since2 =
| leaders_seat2 =
| last_election2 =
| seats2 = 13
| seat_change2 =

| title =
| before_election =
| before_party =
| after_election =
| after_party =
}}

The first election for a legislative assembly called ''Praja Sabha'' was held in 1934 in the [[princely state]] of [[Jammu and Kashmir (princely state)|Jammu and Kashmir]] in the [[British Indian Empire]]. The Praja Sabha was to have 75 members, of which 12 would be officials, 33 elected members and 30 nominated members.{{efn|name=nominated|The President of the Assembly, Sir Barjor Dalal, makes a distinction between 14 members nominated to constituencies on account of infeasibility of holding elections to them, and 16 members nominated as state councillors.{{sfnp|Dalal, The Jammu and Kashmir State Assembly|1935|p=144}}}} The election was held on 3 September 1934. The [[All Jammu and Kashmir Muslim Conference (1934–1939)|All Jammu and Kashmir Muslim Conference]] under the leadership of [[Sheikh Abdullah]] was the largest elected party with 16 seats won. A 'Liberal Group' championed by the [[Dogra Sadar Sabha]] had the overall majority in the Assembly with 24 members.<ref name="Dalal results">
{{harvp|Dalal, The Jammu and Kashmir State Assembly|1935|p=146}}. The elected members of the Liberal Group are not specified, but they can be inferred to be 13 in number, based on other data. The rest were nominated members. Two members of the Muslim Conference later switched to the Liberal Group, increasing its strength to 26.
</ref>

==Constitution of the Praja Sabha==
Maharaja [[Hari Singh]] of [[Jammu and Kashmir (princely state)|Jammu and Kashmir]] established a Franchise Committee under the chairmanship of Sir Burjor Dalal{{efn|Sir Burjor Dalal was a former member of the [[Indian Civil Service]], and served as a judge of the [[Allahabad High Court]]. He was appointed by the Maharaja to chair the inquiry commission on the government's handling of the [[1931 Kashmir agitation]]. Its report has been described as an "outspoken document".<ref>[http://archive.spectator.co.uk/article/7th-november-1931/9/the-kashmir-troubles- The Kashmir Troubles], The Spectator, 7 November 1931.</ref>}}
on 31 May 1932 to make recommendations for establishing a ''Praja Sabha'' (literally, "Subjects' Assembly") in State. The recommendations came a year later with the proposal for a 75-member assembly in which 33 would be elected members, 30 would be nominated members and 12 would be officials.<ref name=Franchise>[http://ikashmir.net/historicaldocuments/51.html Report of the Franchise Committee 1933], 30 December 1933, Kashmir Historical Documents, Kashmiri Pandit Network, retrieved 23 April 2018.</ref>{{efn|name=nominated}}

The 33 elected members would be further split across religious communities, with 21 seats allocated to Muslims, 10 to Hindus and 2 to Sikhs.{{sfnp|Saraf, Kashmiris Fight for Freedom, Volume 1|1977|p=486}}

With regard to provinces, the [[Kashmir Division|Kashmir province]] was allocated 16 seats (11 Muslim, 3 Hindu and 1 Sikh). The [[Jammu Division|Jammu province]] was allocated 17 seats (9 Muslim, 7 Hindu and 1 Sikh). The [[Ladakh wazarat|Ladakh]] and [[Gilgit wazarat|Gilgit]] ''wazarats'' (districts) only had nominated members (2 and 1 respectively). The internal jagir of [[Chenani]] was allocated a nominated member.

==Political background==
Prior to the election, Sheikh Abdullah's position was said to be shaky. The most active members of the Muslim Conference party were in prison for having participated in the [[1931 Kashmir agitation|agitation]]. The younger members were in rebellion, and many joined a rival 'Azad' Muslim Conference started by [[Mirwaiz Yusuf Shah]]. Abdullah was suspected of having links to [[Ahmadiyya]]s and his marriage to the daughter of Englishman was also unpopular. Nevertheless he presented a moderate face of the party and the British government as well as the Maharaja's government was inclined to provide him encouragement.{{sfnp|Copland, Islam and Political Mobilization in Kashmir|1981|pp=250–252}}

However, the government was not entirely cooperative. It is said to have promised that the political prisoners would be released prior to the election, but backtracked on it three hours before the deadline for nominations. Consequently, the Muslim Conference had to fall back on second-rate candidates. Abdullah was bitter: "The Kashmir Government wants to squeeze me [out] by pouncing upon me", was his caustic remark.{{sfnp|Copland, Islam and Political Mobilization in Kashmir|1981|p=253}}

The proposed Legislative Assembly did not meet the expectations of the Muslim Conference. Nevertheless, Abdullah persuaded his followers that they should participate in the elections "if only to show the extent of [the] popular support enjoyed" by the party. However, [[Chaudhry Ghulam Abbas]], imprisoned in Udhampur jail, was steadfast in his disapproval. Finally, the general council of the party approved the move on 27 August 1934.{{sfnp|Hussain, Sheikh Abdullah - A Biography|2016|p=244}}

Sheikh Abdullah campaigned vigorously and turned the tide in his favour. The main contest was in the city of Srinagar, where five Muslim seats were contested by Abdullah's Muslim Conference and Yusuf Shah's Azad Muslim Conference.{{sfnp|Hussain, Sheikh Abdullah - A Biography|2016|p=247}}

==Election and results==
Elections for the Praja Sabha seats were held on 3 September 1934.{{sfnp|Dalal, The Jammu and Kashmir State Assembly|1935|p=143}}

Abdullah's Muslim Conference won all five seats in Srinagar, defeating Yusuf Shah's Azad Muslim Conference. Abdullah's biographer Syed Tafazull Hussain finds this remarkable since Yusuf Shah was a respected religious figure of longstanding while Abdullah was only a recent arrival.{{sfnp|Hussain, Sheikh Abdullah - A Biography|2016|p=247}}

All the other seats were uncontested according to Justice [[Yusuf Saraf]].{{sfnp|Saraf, Kashmiris Fight for Freedom, Volume 1|1977|p=488}}

In the final tally, the Muslim Conference had 16 elected seats in the Assembly, and the Liberal Group championed by [[Dogra Sadar Sabha]] had 13. According to the President of the Assembly, 2 Muslim Conference members switched their allegiance to the Liberal Group after two-and-half weeks of the Assembly session. Several nominated members also joined the Liberal Group, taking its final tally in the Assembly to 26.<ref name="Dalal results"/>{{efn|Several scholarly sources state that the Muslim Conference had won 14 seats.{{sfnp|Copland, Islam and Political Mobilization in Kashmir|1981|p=253}}{{sfnp|Korbel, Danger in Kashmir|1966|p=19}}{{sfnp|Das Gupta, Jammu and Kashmir|2012|p=60}} This would appear to be a misreading of the Sir Burjor Dalal's information.}} Dalal states that a Pandit Party (Kashmir Pandit Yuvak Sabha) had 3 seats and a Sikh Party had another 3 seats.{{sfnp|Dalal, The Jammu and Kashmir State Assembly|1935|p=147}}

The Muslim Conference in the Assembly was led by Mian Ahmad Yar, with [[Mirza Afzal Beg]] as the deputy leader.{{sfnp|Hussain, Sheikh Abdullah - A Biography|2016|p=248}} The Liberal Group was led by Ram Chander Dubey.<ref name=Dubey>
{{harvp|Khan, Freedom Movement in Kashmir|1980}}: 'After having heard the Finance Minister, the leader of the Liberal Party, Mr. Ram Chander Dobey said, "The elected members had no alternative but to register their protest by staging a walk-out."'
</ref>

== Aftermath ==
Sheikh Abdullah, who had already expressed [[secularism in India|secular views]] prior to the election, forged a working relationship with the Liberal Group. By the end of the first session, he expressed satisfaction with the "sympathetic attitude of the President and the Ministers."{{sfnp|Copland, Islam and Political Mobilization in Kashmir|1981|p=253}}

Soon frictions developed. The elected members got frustrated with their inability to achieve policy changes, and, by March 1935, 29 elected members (14 belonging to the Muslim Conference and 15 to the Liberal Group) submitted a memorandum to the Maharaja asking for the constitution to be revised so as to make the executive responsible to the Legislature. The Kashmiri Pandit party did not participate in the demand.{{sfnp|Khan, Freedom Movement in Kashmir|1980|p=259}} From here onward, demand for [[responsible government]] became the rallying cry for the elected legislators. By 2 November 1936, Sardar Budh Singh (Sikh member elected from Mirpur and Poonch) and the Muslim Conference members charged the government with "breach of trust" and resigned ''en masse''. The Maharaja accepted the resignations and called by-elections for those seats.{{sfnp|Khan, Freedom Movement in Kashmir|1980|p=268}}

By-eletions were held in July 1937. The Muslim Conference returned the same candidates that had resigned previously.{{sfnp|Khan, Freedom Movement in Kashmir|1980|p=268}}

Subsequently, the Maharaja appointed the liberal politician-administrator, Sir [[N. Gopalaswami Ayyangar]] as the prime minister for the state.

==Notes==
{{notelist}}

==References==
{{reflist|30em}}

==Bibliography==
* {{citation |first=Sumantra |last=Bose |author-link=Sumantra Bose |title=Kashmir: Roots of Conflict, Paths to Peace |publisher=Harvard University Press |year=2003 |ISBN=0-674-01173-2 |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=3ACMe9WBdNAC |ref={{sfnref|Bose, Kashmir: Roots of Conflict, Paths to Peace|2003}}}}
* {{citation |last=Copland |first=Ian |title=Islam and Political Mobilization in Kashmir, 1931-34 |journal=Pacific Affairs |volume=54 |number=2 |date=1981 |pp=228–259 |JSTOR=2757363 |ref={{sfnref|Copland, Islam and Political Mobilization in Kashmir|1981}}}}
* {{citation |last=Dalal |first=Sir Barjor |title=The Jammu and Kashmir State Assembly: First Session |journal=Asiatic Review |volume=31 |year=1935 |pp=137–147 |url=https://archive.org/details/in.gov.ignca.25522/page/143/mode/2up |via=archive.org |ref={{sfnref|Dalal, The Jammu and Kashmir State Assembly|1935}}}}
* {{citation |last=Das Gupta |first=Jyoti Bhusan |title=Jammu and Kashmir |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=dpTpCAAAQBAJ&pg |date=2012 |orig-year=first published 1968 |publisher=Springer |ISBN=978-94-011-9231-6 |ref={{sfnref|Das Gupta, Jammu and Kashmir|2012}}}}
* {{citation |last=Hussain |first=Syed Taffazull |title=Sheikh Abdullah-A Biography: The Crucial Period 1905-1939. 2016 Edition |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=7RwFAQAAQBAJ&pg=PA266 |year=2016 |publisher=Syed Taffazull Hussain |ISBN=978-1-60481-603-7 |ref={{sfnref|Hussain, Sheikh Abdullah - A Biography|2016}}}}
* {{citation |last=Khan |first=Ghulam Hassan |title=Freedom movement in Kashmir, 1931-1940 |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=XiRuAAAAMAAJ |year=1980 |publisher=Light & Life Publishers |ref={{sfnref|Khan, Freedom Movement in Kashmir|1980}}}}
* {{citation |last=Korbel |first=Josef |author-link=Josef Korbel |title=Danger in Kashmir |publisher=Princeton University Press |edition=second |year=1966 |orig-year=first published 1954 |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=7Q7WCgAAQBAJ |ref={{sfnref|Korbel, Danger in Kashmir|1966}}}}
* {{citation |last=Saraf |first=Muhammad Yusuf |author-link=Muhammad Yusuf Saraf |title=Kashmiris Fight for Freedom, Volume 1 |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=_egBAAAAMAAJ |year=1977 |publisher=Ferozsons |ref={{sfnref|Saraf, Kashmiris Fight for Freedom, Volume 1|1977}}}}
** {{citation |last=Saraf |first=Muhammad Yusuf |title=Kashmiris Fight for Freedom, Volume 1 |year=2015 |orig-year=first published 1977 by Ferozsons |publisher=National Institute Kashmir Studies |location=Mirpur |ref={{sfnref|Saraf, Kashmiris Fight for Freedom, Volume 1|2015}}}}

{{Jammu and Kashmir elections}}

{{#seo:
|keywords=1934 elections in India
|description=
}}

[[Category:1934 elections in India]]
[[Category:State Assembly elections in Jammu and Kashmir|1934]]

1934 Jammu and Kashmir Praja Sabha election - Revision history

MetaBOT at 13:56, 8 July 2023